Future of Sex
tagline
  • Remote Sex
  • Virtual Sex & Entertainment
  • Robots
  • Human Augmentation
  • Sex Tech
  • Dating & Relationships
  • Bizarre Bazaar 18+
  • Future of Sex Community
  • Remote Sex
  • Virtual Sex & Entertainment
  • Robots
  • Human Augmentation
  • Sex Tech
  • Dating & Relationships
  • Bizarre Bazaar 18+
  • Future of Sex Community
  • A Day to Come: Imaging What Your Sexlife Might Be Like in the Not-To-Distant Future

  • Arms Enough for Love: The Erotic Possibilities Extra Limbs, More Thumbs May Hand Us

  • Hot Times Ahead: Tomorrow’s Male Contraceptives May Be More About Temperature, Less About Drugs

  • This Bot’s in Love With You—Sincerely or Merely a Revenue Strategy?

  • 10 Best Masturbation Sites on the Web

  • Oh, Canada! Newest, Sexiest Hotel Room in the World Is Just Across the US/Canadian Border

  • Machinery of Joy: Is AI Already Making Sexwork Obsolete?

  • Tomorrow’s Programmable Matter Sextoys Will Be Everything We Want—Whenever We Want It

Future of Sex is supported by our readers. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Home > Robots > Gay Abandon: Drag Queens Expose Flaw In AI-driven Social Media Moderation

Robots
Home›Robots›Gay Abandon: Drag Queens Expose Flaw In AI-driven Social Media Moderation

Gay Abandon: Drag Queens Expose Flaw In AI-driven Social Media Moderation

By M. Christian
October 1, 2020
2324
0

The danger of software’s inability to tell “mock impoliteness” from actual online abuse.

RuPaul appears on Drag Race the TV show.

“It’s important to remember that you’re born naked, and the rest is drag.”

—RuPaul

In response to the escalating number of hate speech incidents, technology giants like Google have begun to lean more and more on artificial intelligence to help identify them.

In a perfect world, this would make the Internet an ultimate safe space, where everyone, no matter their gender expression or sexual orientation, could express themselves, and make connections without fear of harassment. Or worse.

But we don’t live in a perfect world.

In fact, according to a study conducted by members of INTERNETLAB, this dependence on machine learning could make things far worse by silencing the LGBTQIA community instead of supporting it.

Revealed by the flamboyant outrageousness, and playfully catty attitudes, of the gloriously queer queens of drag.

Toxic tweets

For their research, Alessandra Gomes, Thiago Oliva, and Dennys Antonialli fed tweets from Twitter users espousing far-right views, neutral or progressive ones as a control, and then participants in RuPaul’s Drag Race into the Perspective machine learning system.

Created by Jigsaw, that’s owned by Alphabet Inc.—which is part of the Google empire—Perspective analyzed these 114,204 tweets to identify the “toxicity” of any potential language used within them.

The results were profoundly disturbing, to put it mildly, with the AI red-flagging posts from the drag performers at a substantially higher rate than those from vocal homophobes, neo-Nazis, and even the 45th President of the United States.

As Perspective put it:

On average, drag queens’ accounts toxicity levels ranged from 16.68% to 37.81%, while white supremacists’ averages ranged from 21.30% to 28.87%; Trump’s lies at 21.84%.

Perspective also incorrectly identified words that, while they can be used as pejoratives and insults, have also been reclaimed by the LGBTQIA community:

Most of these words had significantly high levels of toxicity: BITCH – 98.18%; FAG – 91.94%; SISSY – 83.20%; GAY – 76.10%; LESBIAN – 60.79%; QUEER – 51.03%; TRANSVESTITE – 44.48%.

Plainly, while tremendously useful at collecting and then correlating data, artificial intelligence still can’t frame the context of what’s found: throwing the baby out with the bathwater, so to speak.

Words as self-armor

Two drag queens appear on Drag Race the TV show.

But what is the context here?  

First, let’s accept that you’d have to be a determined cave-dweller to be utterly unfamiliar with RuPaul’s Drag Race, and a pathological recluse to know absolutely zip about this long-standing tradition of these extravagantly festive performances.

And right along with the high heels, massive wigs, feather boas, and shimmering sequins—to name only a few fashion choices—where’s often the wielding of another all-important fashion accessory: a razor-sharp wit.

Sean McKinnon’s study for the Journal of Language and Sexuality points out that through on the surface these insults look hostile, in reality, they are playful and positive, perceived by “in-group members who recognize the importance of building a thick skin to face a hostile environment from LGBT and non-LGBT people.”

INTERNETLAB bolsters this tradition of “mock impoliteness” by referencing scholars, who say “a sharp tongue is a weapon honed through frequent use, and is a survival skill for those who function outside genteel circles.”

This comes close, but only close, to explaining why Perspective does such a phenomenally poor job of telling bitchy playfulness from actual hate speech.

There’s a deeper issue, however; one that’s intrinsically connected to not only the flaw in Perspective’s programming but in Internet giants like Google even considering their use to moderate social media.

Tech giants and the power to do better

A drag queen wears a blonde wig.

It’s tough to know where to go from here. It’s tempting to start by suggesting that by building systems like Perspective with an aim to limit hate speech on the Internet, social media companies and Internet providers are at least acknowledging a widespread problem exists.

But in light of the on-going—and well-documented—accusations that Facebook, Twitter, and Google’s mismanaged moderation of user content have made an already bad situation much worse, it’s getting tougher and tougher to give them any kind of positive credit.

There’s also the issue of using machine learning at all.

Agreed, the job of trying to moderate the entire internet is flat-out impossible without this kind of assistance, but why not at least try to build into these kinds of systems a sense of context or at least more diligent human oversight.

As it is now, even without systems like Perspective being put in place, people are getting routinely blocked on social media for calling out hate speech when the original toxic posters are allowed to continue.

Similarly, sexual educators, queer activists, trans supporters, sex workers, and tragically too many others to name, are flagged—again while avowed homophobes and white supremacists post with impunity.

Something’s got to give. Clearly, machines can’t do it all—especially when technology companies are woefully ignorant of queer culture—but then neither can humans.

What’s needed is a drag queen’s snap-snap-snap attitude towards this entire issue: a dramatic and powerful movement for the likes of Google to get their act together, bitches!

Otherwise, let’s call them out like Alaska did to Adore on RuPaul’s Drag Race “—these other girls are gonna say you have terrible makeup skills, you have no fashion sense, and you’re dumb as a rock. But they’re wrong! You don’t have terrible makeup skills.”

Image sources: RuPaul’s Drag Race,

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

M. Christian

M.Christian (they/them) loves nothing better than exploring the intersections of sex and technology—and speculating on the future of both. A highly regarded erotica writer they have six novels,12 collections, 100+ short stories, and 25 anthologies as an editor to their name. Their non-fiction regularly appears in many sites, but they're most proud of being a regular contributor to Future of Sex.

Of their erotic fiction, Tristan Taormino said that “M.Christian is a literary stylist of the highest caliber: smart, funny, frightening, sexy—there's nothing [they] can't write about… and brilliantly.”

Reflecting their unique ability to sympathetically and convincingly write for a range of genders and sexual orientations, their stories have appeared in multiple editions of Best American Erotica, Best Gay Erotica, Best Lesbian Erotica, The Mammoth Books of Erotica, and others. Their collection of gay erotic fiction, Dirty Words, was a finalist for the Lambda Literary Award.

While a majority of their stories have been collected into books like Dirty Words, their fondness for combining sex and science fiction is clearly evident in collections that include Rude Mechanicals, Technorotica, Better Than The Real Thing, Skin Effect Effect, Bachelor Machine, and Hard Drive: The Best Sci-Fi Erotica of M.Christian.

As a novelist, M.Christian’s versatility is on full display with Running Dry, The Very Bloody Marys, Brushes, Painted Doll; and the somewhat controversial queer BDSM/horror/thrillers Finger's Breadth, and Me2.

M.Christian has worked on the industry’s production side as an Associate Publisher for Renaissance E Books and as a Publisher for Digital Parchment Services. The latter dedicated to celebrating the works of science-fiction legends such as William Rotsler, Jerome Bixby, Jody Scott, Arthur Byron Cover, Ernest Hogan, and James Van Hise.

Covering topics like BDSM safety, sexual education, senior sexuality concerns, queer and gender issues, plus reviewing a variety of sex tech products, M.Christian’s non-fiction has appeared on sites like Kinkly, Tickle.Life, Sexpert, Queer Majority, Sex for Every Body, and—of course—their ongoing work for Future of Sex.

If there’s anything M.Christian enjoys more than writing, it’s teaching. A featured presenter, sometimes with their friend Ralph Greco Jr, at national sex and BDSM events, they have lectured on kink play (with an emphasis on safety), polyamory, boosting sexual creativity, and erotica writing--for beginners or those wanting to go pro.

M.Christian is a cohost on two popular sex-education podcasts: Love’s Outer Limits with Dr. Amy Marsh and Licking Non-Vanilla with Ralph Greco, Jr.
Previous Article

It’s Raining Men in Gay Harem, an ...

Next Article

MysteryVibe’s Poco Is a Bendy Bullet Vibe ...

Related articles More from author

  • Robots

    Pole-dancing Robot Stripper Performs at Melbourne Sexpo

    December 7, 2016
    By Jasmine van den Hoek
  • Dating & RelationshipsRobots

    Sophia the Robot Confuses Sex and Love—or Does She?

    December 13, 2019
    By M. Christian
  • Robots

    Satisfy a Robot in Free Online Sex Game Erotica Robotica

    May 25, 2016
    By Antony Scholefield
  • An interior robotic view of Henry the animatronic male sex doll's brain.
    Robots

    Here’s Henry, the Hunky Male Sex Robot You’ve Been Waiting For

    February 28, 2018
    By Jenna Owsianik
  • RobotsSex Tech

    Autoblow AI Update: Robot Gives Good Fellatio, Thanks to Machine Learning

    November 24, 2019
    By M. Christian
  • The Foundation for Responsible Robotics released a report exploring the state of sex robots and related ethical concerns.
    Robots

    Sexbot Report Sparks Ethical Debate on Child Sex Robots

    August 2, 2017
    By Future of Sex

  • Virtual Real Porn allows users to feel the action of erotic VR videos with sex toys.
    Virtual Sex & EntertainmentImmersive Entertainment

    Sex Toys Sync with Virtual Reality Pornography for More Immersive Experience

  • Augmentation

    Stem Cell Therapy Could Treat Female Sexual Arousal Disorders

  • RobotsSex Tech

    Eudemonic and More Utopian: Simon Dubé Discusses Sexbots, Sextech, and Other Sexuality Advancements

Virtual Lust is a 3D interactive sex game.
3DXChat
Discover the best virtual sex parties and 3D sex worlds.
  • TOP REVIEWS

  • Harmony ai sex doll from RealDoll

    State of the Sexbot Market: The World’s Best Sex Robot and AI Sex Doll Companies ...

  • Realistic Sex Games

    Review of the Best Sex Games and Most Realistic Sex Simulators [UPDATED]

    0
  • Screenshot of a sexbot from adult entertainment game

    The Best Adult Games on Steam [UPDATED]

  • Screenshot of FeelConnect app future of interactivity intimacy available on Apple and Google Store

    The Best Sex Game Apps for Couples [UPDATED]

  • Project QT is the most popular RPG sex game at hentai sex game portal Nutaku.

    The Best RPG Sex Games [UPDATED]

Fantasy sex game Dream Sex World lets you explore your wildest desires.
Multiplayer sex world Red Light Center continues to impress with its massive userbase and incredible sex graphics.
A blonde and light-skinned love doll face sppears next to the text Go now realdollxthe future is real.

Like Us on Facebook

Newsletter Subscription

Sign up for our monthly newsletter sharing the very best of the future of sex from our publication and others across the web.

DreamSexWorld offers a stunning XXX 3D world filled with incredibly interactive erotic experiences.

Like Us On Facebook

Facebook Pagelike Widget

RLC_ad_v2

Tweets by @FutureofSex
Future of Sex Report

Follow us

  • Home
  • About
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contribute
  • Story Ideas
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2011 - 2022 Future Exploration Network
This website or its third-party tools use cookies to improve user experience and track affiliate sales. To learn more about why we need to use cookies, please refer to the Privacy Policy.

By clicking the agree button or continuing to browse through the website, you agree to the use of cookies. Accept Privacy Policy
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT