Future of Sex
tagline
  • Remote Sex
  • Virtual Sex & Entertainment
  • Robots
  • Human Augmentation
  • Sex Tech
  • Dating & Relationships
  • Bizarre Bazaar 18+
  • Future of Sex Community
  • Remote Sex
  • Virtual Sex & Entertainment
  • Robots
  • Human Augmentation
  • Sex Tech
  • Dating & Relationships
  • Bizarre Bazaar 18+
  • Future of Sex Community
  • Machinery of Joy: Is AI Already Making Sexwork Obsolete?

  • Tomorrow’s Programmable Matter Sextoys Will Be Everything We Want—Whenever We Want It

  • Men’s Only Club: Does the Synthetic Companion Industry Really Have a Sexism Problem?

  • Red States, Risqué Secrets: Who’s Really Obsessing Over Sex?

  • No Hentai, Please: Japan Prosecutes AI Porn Prompters

  • Out of Sight, Out of Touch? Sweden Moves to Ban Adult Cam Performers

  • Spin Me Right Round: Cupsland’s Twirl Does Everything A Stroker Should—And More

  • We-Vibe Sextech Report: Talk, Grab a Toy, and Enjoy

Future of Sex is supported by our readers. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Home > Sex Tech > Deepfake Erotica Doesn’t Need New Laws, Which May Restrict Sexual Fantasies and Promote the Prison System

Sex TechVirtual Sex & EntertainmentImmersive Entertainment
Home›Sex Tech›Deepfake Erotica Doesn’t Need New Laws, Which May Restrict Sexual Fantasies and Promote the Prison System

Deepfake Erotica Doesn’t Need New Laws, Which May Restrict Sexual Fantasies and Promote the Prison System

By Lara Karaian
August 24, 2024
961
0

Reprinted from The Conversation with the author’s permission

After deepfakes of Taylor Swift went viral on the social media platform X (formerly Twitter), Swifties sprung into action. They organized to report violations of X’s “Synthetic and Manipulated Media” policy and flooded the platform with real images of Swift in an attempt to alter X’s algorithm.

The incident renewed calls for federal legislation regarding deepfake erotica. But whether we need to “defeat” deepfakes by censoring and criminalizing it is up for debate—or at least it should be. 

As a criminologist and sexuality studies scholar with expertise in the legal regulation of sex and sexual expression, the push to conflate deepfakes with misogyny and sexual harm is concerning, as is the call for new criminal laws.

Are deepfakes sexual violence?

Deepfake refers to the use of artificially intelligent (AI) machine-learning applications to generate original but “fake” audio, images or videos that may appear authentic. Deepfake pornography (DFP) refers to products that are sexually explicit in nature. 

According to a 2023 report by cybersecurity firm Home Security Heroes, DFP makes up 98 per cent of all deepfake videos online, and 99 per cent of DFP features women. Notably, 94 percent of these women work in the entertainment industry. 

An earlier study of DFP by Deeptrace Labs found that of those in the entertainment industry, most of the 10 most frequently represented individuals were actresses from western countries, followed by South Korean K-pop singers.

Given their gendered, sexual and seemingly “non-consensual” nature, DFP has been widely described as gender-based sexual violence requiring greater civil and criminal regulation of both AI and deepfake porn producers. 

Others, however, suggest that deepfake erotica may be deeply constitutional sexual expression, and that new laws should be put off until more research about the impacts of pornographic deepfakes on those depicted, as well as on internet users, can be conducted. 

Deepfakes raise concerns about false representations—for instance, falsely depicting an individual as sexually active, into a certain type of sex or involved in the adult entertainment industry. Whether this constitutes sexual violence—even if a person is distressed by fake videos of them—is not self-evident.

Many valid reasons exist for why deepfakes may be created and shared, and why it should not be interpreted or criminalized as “image based sexual abuse” or “virtual rape.” These reasons include, but are not limited to the social value of sexual fantasy—including seemingly “deviant” fantasies—and the need to resist prison expansionism and the carceral state.

Need for new laws?

Deepfakes, as with the cheapfakes that preceded them, can be created for malicious purposes including harassment, spreading disinformation and extortion. In instances where the use of one’s image is deeply upsetting to the individual depicted, legal avenues such as civil privacy, intentional infliction of emotional distress, invasion of privacy laws that address “false light” (making false or misleading claims about a person that cause harm to them) and take-down orders may help address their concerns. 

When it comes to deepfake adult content and minors, Canada’s child pornography and its Intimate Images provisions likely apply. And in cases where DFP images and videos are used to harass or extort individuals, laws already exist to address these harms. On or offline, however, there are reasons to resist pro-criminalization strategies.

Queer and sex-radical feminists have long established that even though sex and gender are related, theories of gender oppression cannot wholly explain sex and sexual politics. Importantly, anti-sexual violence feminists and anti-carceral scholars have pointed out the limits and harms of using criminal law to respond to sexual violence for sexual violence victims, the accused and society more broadly. 

Before we can determine whether sexual violence is the best framework for describing and responding to deepfakes, we need a better understanding of deepfake prosumers—those who produce, consume and share their creations—as well as the importance of sexual fantasy, at the individual and collective levels.

Deepfake prosumers

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to interview or conduct research with deepfake prosumers given how widely they are described as depraved, as the embodiment of “toxic geek masculinity,” and as driven by an interest in owning women’s bodies.

Research suggests, however, that many deepfake creators are hobbyists who are more interested in contributing “to the development of such technology as solving an intellectual puzzle… rather than as a way to trick or threaten people.” 

It’s likely that most deepfake prosumers are men, given what we know about the demographics of computer programmers and porn consumers.

Insights from clinical practice suggests that when men do create fake porn misogyny rarely serves as a key motivator. Clinical psychologist David J. Ley observes that more of these cases are “driven by feelings of loss, shame, hope, and fantasy than by misogyny and anger.” Similar to Photoshopped “porno collages,” deepfakes serve as a means to explore fantasies that are likely impossible to fulfill.

But is sexual fantasy a valid reason to create and share deepfake erotica on public and paid platforms? 

Sexual fantasy and deepfakes

Sexual fantasy is more complicated and more important to our sex lives and to our social well-being than people typically realize or acknowledge. For many, sexual fantasy is private and limited to their mind’s eye.

Others, however, see sexual fantasy as something to be manifested as written text, images or digital files, and publicly shared for free or for a fee. 

Critical race feminist scholars have demonstrated that sexual fantasy is both a product of and productive of our complex realities, but that a line can also be drawn between fantasy and reality given the important roles that fantasy plays in our individual and collective lives.

At the individual level, a study that surveyed 1,516 adult cis men and women about their sexual fantasies found that more than half of the respondents—51.7 percent of women and 61.9 percent of men—fantasized about sex with a celebrity.

Sexual fantasy research has also helped establish that few sexual fantasies are statistically unusual or rare. This includes fantasies which have previously been deemed perverted or atypical, such as those that involve violence or humiliation. These fantasies are not only common, but are also “unlikely to be revealing of actual behavior.”

According to Ley, reasons for publicly sharing sexual fantasies range from seeking approval, demonstrating technical prowess and playing with taboo to bonding with those who share the same interests or to arouse others in the way they are aroused so as to feel less alone for having these interests and desires. 

As legal scholar Andrew Gilden writes: 

“The actual process of coming to terms with one’s sexual identity often entails extensive fantasizing, experimentation, education, and social interaction. And these processes are often far less romantic, much less ‘dignified,’ and far less ‘PG’ than envisioned by the evolving legal narratives of sexuality.”

Consent and fantasy

Thinking about deepfake erotica through the lens of sexual fantasy also helps us make sense of the lack of consent in DFP. Consent does not factor into people’s sexual fantasies in the same ways as it does their physical sexual relations: I don’t need permission to fantasize about someone, but I do need permission to have sex with them. 

Consent is a primarily legal term that, at its most general, means voluntary agreement to engage in sexual activity. The use of consent language to refer to the creative process of DFP as image-based sexual abuse or virtual rape shuts down a nuanced conversation about sexual harm and freedom. 

Expanding definitions

Ultimately, sexual fantasy cannot fully explain the phenomenon of deepfake porn. But failing to acknowledge the limits of gender-based sexual violence frameworks comes with its own harms, including the ever-growing definition of sex crime and the expansion of the carceral state.

We need to think carefully about the social and cultural motivations and intent of content creators, in addition to the potential effects of their creations. We need to consider whether expanding the scope of criminal law to address emotional harm in virtual spaces will bring about the changes we want to see, including the reduction of sexual violence. We also need to acknowledge that criminal law has largely failed to prevent, and indeed perpetuates, emotional and physical violence at a level that requires great awareness and care. 

Concerns about sexual autonomy should inform debates about emerging technologies, but alternative frameworks for making sense of and responding to deepfakes should be considered before we censor and criminalize deepfake adult content producers, consumers and products.

Image Sources: Depositphotos

The Conversation
Tagsartificialintelligencelegislationeroticadeepfakes

Lara Karaian

Lara Karaian is an Associate Professor in the Institute of Criminology
and Criminal Justice at Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada. Her
research examines the intersections between sexuality, technology, and
law. Her current research project, “Sex/Crime in the Era of Immersive,
Interactive, and Intelligent Technologies: A Study of Sextech, Affect,
and Law” (funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research
Council), examines how sextech affects the legal concept of ‘sex
crime’. Lara has served as an Expert Consultant for national and
international studies on youths’ digital sexual expression and as an
expert consultant on numerous criminal cases involving youths’
intimate image distribution. She is an editorial member of the journal
Porn Studies and a Senior Fellow and blogger at Toronto Metropolitan
University’s Centre for Free Expression. Her research has been
published online as well as in numerous peer-reviewed journals and
edited collections.
Previous Article

“Dreams of Flying”—an Erotic Speculative Fiction Story

Next Article

Sensual Spaces: When Architecture, Sex, and VR ...

Related articles More from author

  • Sex TechVirtual Sex & EntertainmentImmersive Entertainment

    Erotica’s Evolution: How the Written Word Will Get More Exciting in the Years Ahead

    August 19, 2024
    By M. Christian
  • Dating & RelationshipsRobotsSex Tech

    Yes, And…Maybe Not: Why Erotic Chatbots May Need Guardrails

    April 10, 2025
    By A.R. Marsh, Ed.D.
  • UncategorizedRobotsSex Tech

    How AI-Powered Sexbots Could Enhance, Not Replace Human Sexuality

    November 20, 2023
    By Karley Sciortino
  • Dating & RelationshipsSex TechVirtual Sex & Entertainment

    Red States, Risqué Secrets: Who’s Really Obsessing Over Sex?

    May 1, 2025
    By A.R. Marsh, Ed.D.
  • VR PornSex TechVirtual Sex & EntertainmentImmersive Entertainment

    Everything That They Want Me to Be: Adult Entertainer Licenses Persona to AI Developer

    December 30, 2024
    By M. Christian
  • RobotsSex TechVirtual Sex & EntertainmentImmersive Entertainment

    Next Century Kinks: Exploring Five Possible Future Fetishes

    October 28, 2024
    By M. Christian

  • Tech Sex Study
    Dating & RelationshipsSex Tech

    We Research Sex; Let Us Tell You About the Future

  • Sex Tech

    The Coolest Sex Tech I Saw at This Year’s AVN Adult Entertainment Expo

  • New After Dark section features Indiegogo's sex tech products,
    Sex Tech

    Indiegogo’s After Dark Collection Shines (Some) Light on Adult Products

Virtual Lust is a 3D interactive sex game.
3DXChat
Discover the best virtual sex parties and 3D sex worlds.
  • TOP REVIEWS

  • Multiplayer Online Sex Games

    Review of the Best Massively Multiplayer Online Sex Games

    0
  • Harmony ai sex doll from RealDoll

    State of the Sexbot Market: The World’s Best Sex Robot and AI Sex Doll Companies ...

  • Realistic Sex Games

    Review of the Best Sex Games and Most Realistic Sex Simulators [UPDATED]

    0
  • Screenshot of a sexbot from adult entertainment game

    The Best Adult Games on Steam [UPDATED]

  • Screenshot of FeelConnect app future of interactivity intimacy available on Apple and Google Store

    The Best Sex Game Apps for Couples [UPDATED]

Fantasy sex game Dream Sex World lets you explore your wildest desires.
Multiplayer sex world Red Light Center continues to impress with its massive userbase and incredible sex graphics.
A blonde and light-skinned love doll face sppears next to the text Go now realdollxthe future is real.

Like Us on Facebook

Newsletter Subscription

Sign up for our monthly newsletter sharing the very best of the future of sex from our publication and others across the web.

DreamSexWorld offers a stunning XXX 3D world filled with incredibly interactive erotic experiences.

Like Us On Facebook

Facebook Pagelike Widget

RLC_ad_v2

Tweets by @FutureofSex
Future of Sex Report

Follow us

  • Home
  • About
  • ADVERTISE
  • Contribute
  • Story Ideas
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
© 2011 - 2022 Future Exploration Network
This website or its third-party tools use cookies to improve user experience and track affiliate sales. To learn more about why we need to use cookies, please refer to the Privacy Policy.

By clicking the agree button or continuing to browse through the website, you agree to the use of cookies. Accept Privacy Policy
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
SAVE & ACCEPT